UPDATE: In the opening keynote for CES 2011, Corporate Vice President Mike Angiulo announced that the ASUS EP121 Slate PC is now available for pre-order online at the Microsoft Store and Amazon.com! To help you determine if the EP121 is right for you, we’ve also launched a dedicated page for the device on Windows.com. Check it out!
CES is in full swing, and it started off with a bang when ASUS formally unveiled the EP121, the company’s new Windows 7-powered slate PC. I was one of the lucky few who were able to get their hands on an EP121 before CES and I’ve been using it as my primary PC for much of the last 2 weeks (I’m even writing this post on it). It’s a capable computer loaded with a Core i5 processor, 4 GB of RAM, Intel HD graphics and a fast 64GB SSD, and it proved to me that Windows 7 does in fact “fit” on a slate.
Look and Feel
Normally I start with performance when I do a hands on review, but the EP121 is so different in its industrial design from a “normal” PC that I wanted to talk about that first and then go into how it handled in all four “modes” – typing with the on-screen keyboard, using the Bluetooth physical keyboard, writing with the included pen, and as a touch-only PC.
The EP121 has a 12.1” 1366 x 768 HD display that is made from capacitive Corning Gorilla Glass, the same material used in my Dell Venue Pro Windows Phone . Gorilla Glass is scratch and shatter resistant, which makes it a smart choice for a device that’s wide and thin and therefore inherently more fragile than a polycarbonate or aluminum chassied laptop. My only gripe about Gorilla Glass is that it’s very glossy so it can be prone to fingerprints. But, like any touch device, it’s a necessary evil – and nothing a tissue, microfiber cloth, pant leg or t-shirt can’t fix in seconds!
The PC is only about 2/3 of an inch thick, which is impressive given the heavy duty specs and full complement of ports (2 covered USB for connecting virtually any peripheral, mini-HDMI to output to a monitor or TV, and an SD card reader). There’s also a spring-loaded enclosure for an intelligent pen, a volume rocker, power button, keyboard call-up button, and screen-rotation lock. Additionally, the EP121 has a forward-facing camera that works great for Windows Live Messenger HD video chat, and a crescent moon shaped button that activates Flip 3D. Normally I don’t use Flip 3D to toggle between windows, but on a PC like this that lacks a traditional mouse it was an easy, fast way to move between my open apps.
The EP121 is lighter than you’d expect – only 2.5 lbs. – and it’s surprisingly comfortable and ergonomic to hold; because the EP121 is widescreen unlike some other slates on the market, it fits nicely between your hand and the crook of your elbow. Cradled that way, typing on the on-screen keyboard with one hand is comfortable for short-bursts, although I wouldn’t want to write a dissertation on it that way. Using the pen is as natural as scribbling in a paper notebook. This is probably what impressed me the most about the EP121; I was expecting an awkward, carpal-tunnel inducing session, and instead, I found myself working, fiddling online, and watching video for as long as I normally do when I’m working on one of my regular laptops. It shows me that the engineers as ASUS put as much thought into the device’s ergonomics and the real-world use scenarios as they did making sure that the EP121 was a capable PC. Very smart.
To make the EP121 even more comfortable to hold, ASUS created a leather folio for the PC. This not only serves as a protective covering but also a functional stand; the folio has built-in supports to prop the EP121 up in portrait and landscape mode, which make watching video and typing on a flat surface much more comfortable. There’s also a slot to hold the pen so you don’t have to pop it in and out of its internal sheath. While the folio does add a some weight and bulk, it’s negated by the added functionality and protection. I kept my EP121 in its folio about 90% of the time I was writing this review.
Performance
It’s important to remember that this is a full PC running Windows 7, so I put it through the same paces that I would any other PC. Not surprisingly, under a normal everyday workload that included most of Office 2010 (Word, Outlook, PowerPoint and OneNote were the applications I used the most), the EP121 performed beautifully. The SSD made a huge difference in opening my gigantic Outlook profile, and the i5 processor handled running those applications, along with Windows Live Writer, Windows Live Mail, Windows Live Messenger, and IE9, without any bottlenecking. Fundamentals were good, too, and delivered really impressive times – particularly for sleep and wake, which were virtually instantaneous:
- Start-up (cold boot to desktop): 19 seconds
- Shut down (no apps open): 17 seconds
- Sleep (to fan off): 1 second
- Wake (to desktop): 1 second
As I mentioned above, typing on the on-screen keyboard was natural and fast and that was more than sufficient for tasks like keeping up on Twitter, posting to Facebook and writing short e-mails. But when I needed to write longer things, like this post, I fired up the included Bluetooth keyboard. As good as the touchable keyboard is I just couldn’t move as fast on it as I do on a physical keyboard. Fortunately the keyboard is lightweight so I didn’t might carrying it around in my bag, and it connects almost instantly so there’s no complicated setup. If I was on a short day trip I probably wouldn’t bring the keyboard, but I would keep it close at hand if I needed to do some serious writing.
I used the pen almost exclusively for taking notes in OneNote (although I did spend some time practicing my calligraphy using the HTML5 site “The Shodo” in IE9). The pen is “smart”, as in it knows where it is above the glass, and the “eraser end” of the pen works as - surprise! - an eraser that wipes away text on the screen if you make a mistake. Writing is smooth and easy, just like with a real pen. There’s very little parallax (i.e., the difference between where the pen touches the glass and where the “ink” appears) and zero lag, so I could scrawl away just as fast as I do on paper. In meetings I found this to be a much more thoughtful way of taking notes than typing. Here’s why: with a traditional laptop you have the screen in front of you which walls you off from the conversation. It’s also loud and unless you’re a professional stenographer, you spend more time looking at the screen or keys than your colleague. With the EP121 and the pen you take notes just like you would in a paper notebook, so you spend more time engaging with the presenter, rather than managing keystrokes. It’s an unobtrusive to be productive with technology.
To make them even more useful, I set up my OneNote notebooks to sync through SkyDrive so I could pull them up on my other laptops and pick up right where I left off. It was kind of cool to have a page that was half-written/half-typed. Enough so that I might even give up my my trusty yellow notepad and blue ballpoint. Sorry, old friend…
While I liked the pen for note-taking, my 2-year-old daughter Audrey loved it for something else – drawing. I loaded ArtRage Starter on the EP121, and gave it to Audrey to doodle. She picked up how to work with touch and the pen almost instantly and in a few minutes was coloring and finger-painting as fast as she does on paper.
As you’d expect with Windows 7, touch was outstanding. Scrolling, pinching and rotating were smooth and fast, the glass was responsive even to light touch, and Windows 7’s built-in gestures are very natural to use on this form factor. I especially liked using PowerPoint on the EP121; it was really easy – and kind of fun – to flick from slide to slide in presentation mode.
The EP121’s Intel HD graphics were more than enough to play smooth, stutter-free video on YouTube, Microsoft.com and ESPN, and I could even watch two NFL highlight clips at the same time in separate IE9 windows Snapped to the left and right side of the screen without issue. My favorite was watching TV using Hulu Desktop. One of the things that’s quite cool about the EP121’s industrial design is the massive viewing angle - ASUS claims 175 degrees of viewability, and while I didn’t bust out my protractor to check, I would say that it’s accurate. My wife, daughter and I watched some Sesame Street together on the couch and all three of us could see the video easily.
The GPU performed well with HD video chat in Windows Live Messenger, too, although I will admit that I found myself getting fatigued holding the PC up to chat after a few minutes. In the folio that problem went away as I just propped the EP121 up on the kitchen table and chatted away.
Battery life wasn’t breakthrough like on ASUS’ UL line, which packs more than 12 hours of juice, but it was average for an ultraportable of this thinness. I got about 3.5 hours of work and video watching time out of mine, which while not as exceptional as some laptops, would be more than enough to get through an afternoon meeting or stay up and running on a flight from Seattle to San Francisco.
Final Thoughts
The ASUS EP121 is a capable slate PC and I’ll likely keep one on hand as a companion PC for day trips. It’s also very much at home as a “meeting machine” where its primary function is for presenting and for note taking and as a web-surfing, video-watching “couch companion”. What I enjoyed the most overall was the EP121’s flexibility. Because the engineers at ASUS took full advantage of Windows 7, they were able to include 4 input modes (virtual keyboard, Bluetooth physical keyboard, pen and touch), which means that you’re always able to interact with the PC in the right way at the right time. For me that meant that I could be productive when I needed to be, connected when I wanted to be (to both my friends via mail, HD video chat and Facebook/Twitter, and to my devices like my camera and Zune), and entertained when I needed a break. Would I make it my primary laptop? Probably not. But it’s an excellent companion device and a very viable option for customers looking for an extremely portable slate PC.
Have questions about the ASUS EP121? Hit me on Twitter or send a question in to “Ask Ben Anything”. Your questions might appear in my monthly Q&A column!
And don’t forget, I’ll be on the floor with my camera crew at CES starting tomorrow, so keep an eye on the blog for breaking news and insider access to all of the latest gear from our partners!
PLEASE, DESIGN SOMETHING FOR THE TABLET FORM FACTOR. DON'T BOTHER GOING UP ON STAGE TOMORROW IF ITS JUST WINDOWS 7 WITH AN ADD-ON TOUCH UI, YOU NEED A NEW OS THATS ALL-AROUND DESIGNED FOR TOUCH!!! (OR AT LEAST FOR NOW, UNTIL WINDOWS 8, A VERSION OF WINDOWS THATS ABSOLUTELY ONLY FOR MOBILE MULTI-TOUCH DISPLAYS).
DON'T EMBARRASS YOURSELVES TOMORROW LIKE LAST YEAR. JUST TRYING TO HELP. IT WOULD BE NICE IF SOMEONE INSIDE MICROSOFT ACTUALLY ACKNOWLEDGED THESE THINGS AND TRIED TO ACT ON IT ASAP (AT LEAST SOMEONE OTHER THAN JOE BELFIORE, THE MAN CANT DO IT BY HIMSELF).
@Interframe1 - thank you for the feedback/comment! I think your Caps lock was on ;-)
Two curious questions for you that weren't quite covered...
1 - Is there a chance that a matte screen will be released instead of the glossy. I know that glossy looks great and all, but from a usability perspective seeing a reflection of yourself in a screen can be highly distracting when working.
2 - Is the device usable outdoors? I noticed you mention the viewing angle indoors, but wondering if it's usable for individuals that are outdoors?
Overall have to say that the device looks very alluring.
What an embarassment. You get a "tablet" and put windows 7 on it. Ok so now we have a tablet that gets what, 4 hours battery at best? The UI is not built for touch, it will be hard to use. I'm seriously dissapointed, Microsoft. You could have ported some kind-of Zune UI to it at least. I know that would take a lot of time, but don't push out crap when you have no other option.
Good job on the review Ben. Inasmuch as I admire Windows 7 on a tablet form, I'm still holding out hope for WP7 to show up on a tablet. Talk about something stunning to have and to use. MS would sell millions of them. With Samsung doing the hardware, it would be too sweet.
I just can't use pen on the tablets if my hand can't rest on the screen while writing, especially with screen this big.. Does anybody knows if this problem has been solved?
I honestly have to agree, Windows 7 doesn't really have a Touch Centric interface like the iPad or Android. If anybody believes it does, they are seriously fooling themselves. Microsoft has the technology with Windows Touch and some elements of the present Windows 7 UI are touch ready such as the Windows Taskbar, but other parts need to be revamped. I created a mockup of what a Windows Touch UI should feel like (see here http://bit.ly/eVj4oT). I don't believe a one size fits all is the answer either, so applying the Windows Phone 7 Metro theme or Zune UI is not gonna solve the problems of bringing existing applications forward.
Microsoft needs to evangelize and get teams across the company onboard to optimize their apps with touch ready versions. So, the Office Team needs to work on a version of Word, Excel, PowerPoint that feels like they are designed to be used with your fingers. I don't believe these apps should even be containing every single feature of the desktop version, just the basics, compatibility, alignment, color, collaboration features. The same applies to the Windows Live Team needs to do the same for WIndows Live Essentials. Industry partners will also need to do the same, Adobe I believe is working on optimizing Photoshop for Slates and the iPad, thats a good example of where other software developers need to go.
Certainly the hardware engineering is good, I believe even way better than the iPad, but the software is critical. If Microsoft can get that right, it will definitely be a winner with businesses and consumers.
I thought this product had a docking station so that it could work as a additional battery like ep101. But I can't see one. Only a wireless keyboard. Is asus going to make a docking station for this product?
If not then I think the short battery time will work as a weak spot for this product.
Other than that, I don't have any complain about this product. When I use MIDs or tablet pc using windows OS I usually turn off all the speciallized UIs built by product maker. Because those special UIs take up the system resources. I needed a tablet that uses the exact same windows OS to use in work at the office.
Other products uses different OS or use ATOM grade cpus so I can't use it in my work.
Very great tablet. The battery is too weak, but it is sufficient for major purposes so it is not the biggest problem.
The main problem I see in using Windows Tablets (I own one of them, a convertible multitouch laptop) is that many applications and even the OS are relying on special strokes like CTRL+Click to multiselect items, or ALT to show the menu bar. I think tablets PC should have a few buttons that have the same purpose a the WIN, CTRL, ALT and MAJ keys of the keyboard. It's maybe not as beautiful, but it would really make the tablet more handy. You can't do as if windows programs were touch-ready. Windows 7 may be, but you should take the ecosystem in consideration, too.
Allowing WP7 applications to run on Windows Slates may be a good idea, too.
I have another question about this tablet. I wonder if this tablet implement EFI on it's BIOS. Rescent motherboards made by asus uses EFI implemented BIOS. As you know implementation of EFI can speed up the booting process. I wonder this uses it too.
I believe, it is nonsense, to demand, that Mircosoft should reinvent the iPad, but only do the OS for it, having no Apps on it etc. People will not migrate. Microsoft needs to offer a clear alternative with an open system, that leverages an existing ecosystem of apps addon HW etc. That environment can only be a Windows system. What is lacking are devices. The Asus device is still not on the market. I am using a no name Atom based tab to write this and I love to have Windows 7 on it, to have Outlook, Powepoint and Lync running on it etc. because those are the Apps I want to use. And not somw limited functionality "mobile touch" version of it in a locked down system like the iPad. But where
are the big HW vendors, where is the HP slate, the Asus slate etc.?
Looks like only small companies like Nexoc are willing to bring innovative devices to the market instead of hanging around on fairs with mockups.
www.amazon.de/.../ref=sr_1_5
I hope we will see more devices like these in the near future.
Cheers ... Blackbird
@Brandon ... anything known about availability? There have been devices around at fairs in May 2010 that are not available today and second: Any infos on prices for the EP121 yet?
My primary need in a slate is hand written note taking preferably with OneNote and the occassional editing of Office documents. Can you elaborate on the inking experience a little more? I am a leftie and therefore my palm tends to rest on the writing area. Did you have any problems with inking and having your palm or fingers touch the screen and mess things up? Thanks.
As much as I enjoy Win7, shoving it into a tablet form factor is not going to work. Honestly, the WP7 UI is fantastic. I don't understand why MS doesn't take this beyond the phone.
I would have to disagree with a lot of the comments. I'm very much looking for a device exactly what is described in the post above. I currently have a HP TouchSmart 310-1020 All-in-One Desktop PC that I use in my kitchen that I've been using for over a month now and I'm still amazed at how awesome touch in Win7 works. The device comes with a wireless mouth and keyboard that I don't even put out because the touch interface is so fantastic. I use all the programs I would on my laptop on this device without any hiccups (Windows Live, Office, IE9, Media Center and Zune). As stated above I wouldn't want to write a dissertation on it but I wouldn't on an IPad either.
So I am looking for a mobile extension to my All In One PC and the above device looks and sounds very intriguing and I'm looking forward to when it ships.
Before I purchased and used the All In One PC and used for over a month I was in a similar camp to those who said that MS needs either an over lapping GUI or a complete OS rebuild for slates but after I would say no they don't. HP had a complete overlapping GUI that came with the system and I tried it but uninstalled it after I found it easy to use the programs I love without the mouse and keyboard. I feel most of the naysayers if given the chance to use these systems for any length of time would see the quality of the Win 7 touch interface.
Booooooooooooooo! This is hype without substance. NO mention of the battery life and the price (probably 3-4 hours + at least 999.99). No one wants this garbage. It will not sell.
I have used a Tablet PC (Motion Computing) since 2005 and the only times I would take it with me were for a few meetings and occasional drawing. It basically sat on the shelf because even if the UI works "OK" with the OS, the programs are NOT designed for it.
Windows 7 is not suited for tablets (I notice there is NO PICTURE of the garbage on screen keyboard inherent in Windows 7. Can't Windows AT LEAST compare to the iPad keyboard with an update?). Show us that keyboard. if it is the crappy TIP input panel you can please shove it.
I was a fan of Microsoft Courier and the idea of "Manual Deskterity" (search both on YouTube), but if Ballmer doesn't show me something substantial today I will abandon hope to see anything original. I like a stylus and pressure sensitive drawing and writing, but this ASUS is only a higher spec'd version of the tablet I paid $2,500 for back in 2005. Just because a tablet went down $1,000 in price doesn't mean I will buy it or take it off the shelf either.
You show NO PROGRESS here Microsoft! And to compete in the tablet space you have to have something in the same price range or a compelling feature. If this is all Microsoft shows at the CES Keynote I hope they are boooooo'ed off the stage from their fans, such as I.
Sometimes rooting for you guys at Microsoft is like being a CUBS fan!
Good luck, I will be watching tonight. Show us SOMETHING. And for heaven's sake, LISTEN to the feedback you are getting! How many tablet PCs have you sold to CONSUMERS? I bet in 10 years it is no where near the iPad's first year in sales.
Your fans.
PS... this is a full pound heavier than the iPad? No one will buy it.
Good job to ASUS . but still this thing needs more battery life .3.5 hrs isn't what consumers are hoping for especially given the tablet form factor. It needs to be in the range of 5-6 altleast IMO
How many pressure points does the digitizer have? Very interested in using this for drawing
I would prefer a simpler and cheaper tablet based on the WindowsPhone platform similar to what the iPad did.....
Questions:
Was the digitizer pressure sensative?
Did it have a SIM slot?
What happen to the keyboard that was part of the prototype... i really miss the netbook conversion functionality I was seeing.
@scout @awhitehouse When this device was demonstrated during Ballmer's keynote, the presenter pointed out that not only does it work with a stylus and touch, the interface discriminates so that palm pressure is not confused with touch when you are using the stylus. He illustrated it while annotating an Excel spreadsheet with ink.
@BlackbirdDH The device starts at about $1000, the price increases $100 if you want the larger (64GB) solid-state drive. That puts this machine in a higher price point compared to conventional laptops. I expect there will be an useful range of prices and function when more of the products come on stream and better battery life when the newer processors arrive along with the "future version of Windows.".
@Jessiethe3rd There was no mention of it having a phone in it. I doubt it. The wireless keyboard runs on Bluetooth and is included. As the reviewer says, there are 4 ways to input to the device. I manage to draw on my Tablet PC (2005 Edition) but it probably works best with an on-screen magnifier for precision placement. Not sure what is available for Windows 7 tablet features, but my impression is that stylus support just gets better.
I have my eye on this one as a future replacement for my current Tablet PC (which cannot run anything but XP because the manufacturer does not provide updated drivers). Mostly, I am thrilled to see the innovation in design and creativity of the device manufacturers now that components have become so small. I am also satisfied with this price point for what I want as a future carry-along laptop that I can integrate into my Windows 7 desktop and Windows Phone range of synchronized appliances.
Full Windows on a tablet is great. But until there is a new user interface to allow richer navigation it will NOT take off, asking a user to navigate using a pen like device is not rich user experience. Microsoft should keep the same Windows on tablet but overlay a new UI.
Hello.
What is cooling system?
Active (FAN) or Passive ?
What is noise level ?
Cheers for the write up Ben... outside of Windows, does the EP121 handle professional illustrations/graphics programs? On one hand, Wacom has a 12" screen for roughly $1,200 (Cintiq) that hooks up to a computer, but if I could get the same Wacom style quality with an OS sitting behind it for $200 cheaper it would really be better... not talking 300 dpi images at a grand scale, but maybe some Flash, Illustrator, and some Photoshop painting. I don't even care about the OS as long as it can handle some decent graphic loads.
Any insight would be appreciated... if this thing can do the trick, it would be a solid option for creatives as well as typical office apps.
Thanks in advance if you or anyone else can elaborate!
Looks like a great Tablet. I am asking my company to get it for me :). I am a big fan of Windows 7 and of Windows Phone 7... what about a tablet that would have both OSs and switch between full windows 7 or windows phone 7 (extended version). I think this would be the greatest device ever buit.
Off course, you will also need to find a solution for the low battery life.
Hello Ben,
I just recieved my Asus EP121 today. My only concern is, it will upgrade to Windows 8? I spoke with quiet a few Microsoft representative before I buy the product and the GUEST that the company will. Is a lot of rumors that all currents windows 7 slates won't be able to upgrade to windows 8 because the screen resolution (1280 X 800) is too poor for side to side applications. I'm not looking for Information about windows 8, I'm just need to know for sure is this rumors are false and if we are be able to upgrade to Windows 8.
Thanks.